OnToContent 2008 - Monterrey, Mexico

[ ARCHIVE ] 3rd International Workshop on Ontology content and evaluation in Enterprise

With two tracks on Human Resources and E-Health / AAL

Monterrey, Mexico, Nov 9 - 14, 2008
Proceedings published by Springer Verlag



Under the buzz word Semantic Web a lot of research has been going on in recent years, exploring formalisms for expressing ontologies, reasoning algorithms for inferencing hidden knowledge in an open world, but also on "semantifying" different types of problems. But outside the Semantic Web research community, there has been little uptake so far. This is also due to the fact that the concept of ontology is more about content than formalism, and we are in dire need for content-related research and experiences. As [1] stated, a "good" ontology is a balance of the degree of social agreement, the level of formality, and the appropriateness for the problem at hand that is supposed to be solved with ontologies. In line with this view, the workshop is looking for experiences and empirical results on which formalism is better suited, how to achieve or measure social agreement, and how to judge whether an ontology is appropriate. It is the mission of this workshop to report on these experiences and to reflect them back to the Semantic Web community.

In the area of system design, there is currently a major shift taking place towards user-centered design, and the workshop aims to foster use-centered ontology-based system design. Therefore, we also welcome research and experiences on participatory and evolutionary approaches (i.e., with a continuously high degree of involvement of the actual users) to building and maintaining ontologies that pave the way towards a Web 3.0, bringing together users and semantics.

We also strongly encourage to submit critical papers deriving lessons from failures with "ontologies in the wild", not only stereotypical success reports!

[1] Braun, Schmidt, Walter, Zacharias: The Ontology Maturing Approach to Collaborative and Work-Integrated Ontology Development: Evaluation Results and Future Directions: Emergent Semantics and Ontology Evolution 2007 at ISWC 2007, Busan, Korea, 2007

Workshop Structure and Topics

The workshop will consists of three main parts: a general part on experiences with real-world ontology engineering and approaches to assessment of ontologies, a special track on ontologies in Human Resources and a special track on ontologies in e-health and ambient-assisted living.

  • Towards Web 3.0: a user-centered semantic web
    • Lessons from Web 2.0 for ontology engineering
    • Experiences with participatory and evolutionary approaches to ontology engineering (e.g., based on social software)
    • Lightweight ontology formalisms (e.g., SKOS) and microformats
    • Experiences/empirical results on lightweight vs. heavy-weight ontologies
    • Experiences/empirical results on graphical modeling of ontologies
    • Experimental evidence (e.g., from cognitive science) on conceptual modeling
    • Challenges/requirements for maintenance and evolution of ontologies
    • Good, best, and bad practices  
  • Methods for assessing ontologies
    • Ontology evaluation
    • Quality measures for ontologies
    • Assessment of ontologies with regard to social agreement, formality, and appropriateness
    • Experiences with assessment and evaluations methods
  • Ontologies in Human Resources (Recruiting, Development, Employability)
    • Modeling and representation of: Jobs, CVs, Competencies, Skills, Employees, People, Organizations, Social Events, etc.
    • HR upper level concepts
    • E-Portfolio (standards) and ontologies
    • Semantics of HR-XML
    • Semantic metadata for HR applications
    • Semantics in job matching
    • Semantics in learning technologies
    • Good/Best practices for semantics in HR
    • Maintenance of ontologies in HR  
  • Ontologies in E-Health and Ambient Assisted Living (AAL)
    • Upper level concepts of healthcare and life sciences ontologies.
    • Ontologies of diseases, nursing, therapeutics, drug, etc.
    • Ontologies and ontology-driven approaches in Ambient-Assisted Living
    • Maintenance of ontologies in e-health and AAL

If you feel that something fits into the theme of the workshop, but is not listed here, just contact the organizers.


Andreas Schmidt - [main contact]
FZI Research Center for Information Technologies, Karlsruhe, Germany
E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Mustafa Jarrar
University of Cyprus
E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Program Committee Members

Ernst Biesalski - EnBW AG, Germany
Simone Braun - FZI Research Center for Information Technologies, Germany
Christopher Brewster - University of Sheffield, UK
Thanasis Bouras - National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Michael Brown - Skillsnet.Com
Yannis Charalabidis - National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Ernesto Damiani - Computer Science Department, Milan University, Italy
Panagiotis Gouvas - National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Giancarlo Guizzardi - University of Twente, The Netherlands
Mohand-Said Hacid - University Claude Bernard Lyon 1 LIRIS - Villeurbanne, France
Stijn Heymans - University of Innsbruck, Austria
Christine Kunzmann - Kompetenzorientierte Personalentwicklung, Germany
Stefanie Lindstaedt - Know-Center Graz, Austria
Tobias Ley - Know-Center Graz, Austria
Clementina Marinoni - Fondazione Politecnico di Milano, Italy
Alessandro Oltramari - Laboratory for Applied Ontology, ISTC-CNR, Trento, Italy
Viktoria Pammer - Know-Center Graz, Austria
Paul Piwek - Open University, UK
Christophe Roche - Université de Savoie, France
Peter Scheir - Know-Center Graz, Austria
Pavel Shvaiko - University of Trento, Italy
Miguel-Angel Sicilia - University of Alcalá, Spain
Barry Smith - State University of New York at Buffalo, USA
Armando Stellato - University of Roma, Italy
Karl Stroetmann - Empirica, Germany
Mohammed-Reza Tazari - Fraunhofer IGD, Germany
Sergio Tessaris - Free University of Bozen-Bolzano, Italy
Robert Tolksdorf - Free University of Berlin, Germany
Luk Vervenne - Synergetics, Belgium

Sponsoring institutions/projects

This workshop is organized in a joint effort by the Ontology Outreach Advisory (OOA), the MATURE IP, and the SOPRANO IP.

The OOA is an international not-for-profit association that consists of industry, government, and research leaders and innovators with respect to ontology development, use, or education. The general mission of the OOA is to develop strategies for ontology recommendation and standardization, and promote the ontology technology to industry.

The MATURE IP is a large-scale integrating European project (FP7) in the field of technology- enhanced learning aiming at support of knowledge maturing processes within and across companies, including in particular ontology maturing.

The SOPRANO IP is an integrated European project (FP6) in the field of ambient-assisted living and follows an ontology-driven service-oriented approach to construct a flexible and affordable platform for in-house ambient-assisted living solutions.